Kdy použít ser vs estar — trvalé vs dočasné
Dokáže správně volit mezi ser a estar podle kontextu
Podívejte se na tyto příklady. Dokážete rozpoznat gramatický vzorec?
Maria é inteligente.
Maria je inteligentní.
Maria está feliz.
Maria je šťastná.
O café é quente. / O café está quente.
Káva je horká (obecně). / Káva je horká (teď).
Zaměřte se na zvýrazněné části. Co mají společného?
Both verbs translate as "to be", and English gives you no clue which one to pick. The starting rule works most of the time: ser for what something is - its nature, identity, origin; estar for the state it is in now - how it looks, feels or tastes at this moment, and where it is.
The interesting part is where both are possible, because then the verb changes the message:
| With ser | With estar |
|---|---|
| Ela é bonita. - She is beautiful (that is how she is). | Ela está bonita. - She looks lovely (today, in that dress). |
| Ele é magro. - He is thin (his build). | Ele está magro. - He has got thin (he's lost weight). |
| A sopa é boa. - The soup is good (it's a good recipe). | A sopa está boa. - The soup tastes good (this bowl, now). |
| O café é quente. - Coffee is a hot drink. | O café está quente. - The coffee is hot (careful, don't burn yourself). |
So when a friend tries your feijoada and says Está ótima!, they are praising today's pot. A feijoada da tua avó é famosa describes its reputation.
Treat these as aids, not laws. Events take ser even though they are a "location": O show é no Maracanã.
The habit is to pick one verb and use it for everything, and with adjectives it is usually ser: *Sou cansado, *Sou com fome. Ask each time: is this how the thing is, or how it is right now? And remember that a choice between é and está with the same adjective is often not an error at all - both are Portuguese, they just say different things.
Použijte tuto gramatiku ve cvičeních kurzu A1
Procvičovací cvičeníMaria é inteligente.
Maria je inteligentní.
SER — inteligence je trvalá vlastnost. Popisuje, KDO Maria je.
Maria está feliz.
Maria je šťastná.
ESTAR — štěstí je aktuální emoce, může se změnit. Srovnejte: Maria é feliz (je šťastná povahou).
O café é quente. / O café está quente.
Káva je horká (obecně). / Káva je horká (teď).
SER = káva je obecně horký nápoj. ESTAR = tento konkrétní šálek je teď horký. Obě formy správné, různý význam!
Kontrola k tomuto tématu se připravuje
Připravené nápovědy jsou zdarma
Procvičit v kurzu
Použijte tuto gramatiku ve cvičeních kurzu A1